Direct Shear Apparatus: Working, Step-by-Step Procedure, Importance, Results and Limitations of the Direct Shear Test of Soil

Aimil

Apprentice
Soil is one of the most important materials used in civil engineering and construction. Every building, bridge, road, retaining wall and foundation transfers loads to the soil beneath it. However, soil does not behave like concrete or steel. Its strength depends on several factors, including soil type, moisture content, density, particle arrangement and the pressure acting on it.
One important property of soil is shear strength. It is the ability of soil to resist sliding or failure when a force acts parallel to its surface. If the shear strength of soil is insufficient, problems such as slope failure, foundation settlement, landslides and retaining wall failure may occur.
The Direct Shear Test of Soil is a commonly used laboratory test to determine the shear strength parameters of soil. These parameters are cohesion (c) and the angle of internal friction (φ).
The test is performed using a machine called the Direct Shear Apparatus or Direct Shear Testing Machine. It is relatively simple to operate and is particularly useful for studying the shear behaviour of sandy and other granular soils.
In India, the test is covered under IS 2720 (Part 13):1986 – Methods of Test for Soils: Direct Shear Test, including its applicable amendment. This article explains the working principle, apparatus components, testing procedure, calculations, importance, illustrative results and limitations of the test in simple language.​

​

What Is a Direct Shear Test of Soil?​

The Direct Shear Test is a laboratory method used to determine the resistance of soil against sliding along a predetermined horizontal plane.
In this test, a soil specimen is placed inside a special metal box known as a shear box. The box consists of two halves, one placed above the other. A vertical load is applied to the soil, followed by a horizontal force that gradually pushes one half of the box relative to the other.
As the horizontal force increases, the soil specimen experiences shear stress. The force required to cause failure is measured using a proving ring or load cell.
The test is generally conducted on separate specimens under different normal loads. The maximum shear stress obtained from each test is used to determine the soil's shear strength parameters.
In simple words, the test helps engineers understand how much force the soil can withstand before it starts sliding.
​

Working Principle of Direct Shear Apparatus​

The working principle of the Direct Shear Apparatus is based on the Mohr-Coulomb theory of soil shear strength.
According to this theory, the shear strength of soil depends mainly on two parameters:
Cohesion (c): The component of shear strength associated with bonding or attraction between soil particles.
Angle of internal friction (φ): A measure of the frictional resistance developed between soil particles when they tend to slide against each other.

The relationship is expressed as:
τ = c + σ tan φ

Where:
τ = Shear strength of soil
c = Cohesion of soil
σ = Normal stress acting on the shear plane
φ = Angle of internal friction

When a vertical load is applied to the soil specimen, normal stress develops on the horizontal plane. A horizontal force is then applied to produce relative movement between the two halves of the shear box.
The apparatus measures the horizontal force required to shear the specimen. By repeating the test under different normal stresses, engineers can plot a failure envelope and calculate cohesion and the angle of internal friction.
​

4. Main Components of Direct Shear Apparatus​

A standard Direct Shear Testing Machine consists of several components. Each component performs a specific function during the experiment.

4.1 Shear Box
The shear box is the main component of the apparatus. It is generally square or circular and is divided horizontally into two halves.
The soil specimen is placed inside this box. During testing, one half moves horizontally relative to the other, forcing the soil to shear along the plane between the two halves.

4.2 Loading Frame
The loading frame provides the support required to apply horizontal shear force to the specimen. In a strain-controlled machine, a motor moves the shear box at a selected rate.

4.3 Normal Loading Arrangement
This arrangement applies a vertical load to the soil specimen. Depending on the machine, the load may be applied using a lever system and calibrated weights or another loading mechanism.

4.4 Proving Ring or Load Cell
A proving ring or load cell measures the horizontal shear force developed during the test.
In a proving-ring system, a dial gauge records the deformation of the calibrated ring. The corresponding force is calculated using its calibration factor.

4.5 Horizontal Displacement Dial Gauge
This gauge measures the horizontal movement of the shear box during testing. It helps determine how much the specimen has deformed under the applied shear force.

4.6 Vertical Displacement Dial Gauge
The vertical dial gauge records changes in the specimen's height during loading and shearing.
It helps identify whether the soil undergoes compression or expansion (dilation).

4.7 Porous Stones and Grid Plates
These components are placed above and below the specimen, as required by the test arrangement.
Porous stones help provide drainage, while grid plates improve contact and reduce unwanted slipping between the soil and the loading surfaces.

4.8 Other Accessories​
  • Other accessories include:​
  • Weighing balance​
  • Soil trimming tools​
  • Sample container​
  • Filter papers​
  • Stopwatch​
  • Calibrated weights​
  • Spatula and straightedge​
  • Water container, where required​
​

Importance of the Direct Shear Test​


The Direct Shear Test is important because it provides information about the strength and stability of soil under different loading conditions.
Some major applications are discussed below.​
  1. 1. Foundation design: Engineers use soil shear strength parameters when evaluating the bearing capacity and stability of foundations.​
  2. 2. Slope stability analysis: The test helps determine whether soil on a natural or artificial slope can resist sliding.​
  3. 3. Retaining wall design: Cohesion and friction angle are useful in estimating lateral earth pressure and evaluating soil-wall interaction.​
  4. 4. Road and pavement construction: Soil strength information helps engineers assess the suitability of subgrade and other soil layers.​
  5. 5. Embankment construction: The test helps assess the stability of earth embankments and similar structures.​
  6. 6. Soil improvement projects: Results can be compared before and after stabilisation or other ground improvement treatments.​
  7. 7. Soil-interface studies: Modified direct shear arrangements can be used to investigate friction between soil and materials such as concrete, steel and geosynthetics.​
​

Step-by-Step Procedure of Direct Shear Test​


The following is a general laboratory procedure. The exact specimen preparation, loading arrangement, drainage conditions and testing rate should follow the applicable standard and the laboratory's approved method.
Step 1: Preparation of Soil Sample
First, collect the required soil sample. Prepare the specimen according to the type of soil and the test requirements.
For an undisturbed sample, carefully trim the soil to fit the shear box. For a remoulded sample, prepare the soil at the required moisture content and density.

Step 2: Measurement of Shear Box
Measure the internal length, width and height of the shear box. These dimensions are required to calculate the initial cross-sectional area and the stresses acting on the specimen.

Step 3: Assembly of Shear Box
Assemble the upper and lower halves of the shear box using the locking screws or pins.
Place the required base plate, grid plates, porous stones and filter papers in their correct positions. The arrangement depends on the soil type and whether the test is drained or undrained.

Step 4: Placement of Soil Specimen
Carefully place the prepared soil specimen inside the shear box. Ensure that the soil is distributed properly and that no unwanted gaps are present.
Place the upper grid plate, porous stone and loading pad as required.

Step 5: Installation in Loading Frame
Place the assembled shear box inside the Direct Shear Apparatus. Connect the loading arrangement and ensure that the shear box is properly positioned.

Step 6: Application of Normal Load
Apply the required vertical load to the specimen.
The normal load produces pressure on the horizontal shear plane. Depending on the test condition, the specimen may be allowed to consolidate before shearing begins.

Step 7: Initial Dial Gauge Readings
Set the horizontal and vertical displacement gauges to zero or record their initial readings.
Also check the proving ring or load cell and make sure the measuring instruments are properly calibrated and functioning.

Step 8: Removal of Locking Pins
After the required loading or consolidation stage, carefully remove the locking pins connecting the two halves of the shear box.
Make sure the upper and lower halves can move relative to each other without unwanted contact or obstruction.

Step 9: Application of Horizontal Shear Force
Start the motor or loading mechanism at the selected rate of horizontal displacement.
The horizontal force gradually increases, causing the specimen to shear along the plane between the two halves of the box.

Step 10: Recording of Observations
Record the proving-ring readings and horizontal displacement at regular intervals.
Also record vertical displacement readings to observe compression or expansion of the soil specimen.
Continue the test until the peak shear resistance is reached and sufficient post-peak behaviour has been recorded, or until the specified termination condition is satisfied.

Step 11: Repetition Under Different Normal Loads
Repeat the test using fresh, comparable specimens under different normal loads.
Usually, at least three tests at different normal stresses are used to establish a useful failure envelope, subject to the applicable testing requirements.

Step 12: Calculation and Result Preparation
Calculate the normal stress and shear stress for each test. Plot the maximum shear stress against the corresponding normal stress.
The resulting failure envelope is used to determine cohesion and the angle of internal friction.
​

Calculations Used in the Direct Shear Test​

The main calculations involve normal stress, corrected area, shear stress and shear strength parameters.
​

7.1 Initial Cross-Sectional Area​

For a square shear box:
A₀ = L × B
Where:
A₀ = Initial cross-sectional area
L = Length of specimen
B = Width of specimen
​

7.2 Corrected Area​

As the specimen moves horizontally, the overlapping area of the two halves of the shear box reduces.
For a square specimen, the corrected area can be expressed as:
A = A₀ (1 − δ/L)
Where:
A = Corrected area
A₀ = Initial area
δ = Horizontal displacement
L = Initial length in the direction of shearing
The applicable area correction should follow the relevant standard and the actual shear-box geometry.
​

7.3 Normal Stress​

Normal stress is calculated using:
σ = N/A
Where:
σ = Normal stress
N = Applied normal force
A = Relevant cross-sectional area
​

7.4 Shear Stress​

Shear stress is calculated using:
τ = P/A
Where:
τ = Shear stress
P = Measured horizontal shear force
A = Corrected area at the corresponding displacement
Use consistent units. For example, when force is in newtons and area is in square metres, stress is obtained in pascals.
​

7.5 Determination of Cohesion and Angle of Internal Friction​

After calculating the peak shear stress for each normal stress, plot the results on a graph.
X-axis: Normal stress (σ)
Y-axis: Maximum shear stress (τ)
Draw the best-fit failure envelope through the test points.
According to the Mohr-Coulomb equation:
τ = c + σ tan φ
The vertical intercept of the failure envelope represents cohesion (c), while its slope represents tan φ.
Therefore:
φ = tan⁻¹ (slope)
This gives the angle of internal friction.
​

Results Obtained from the Direct Shear Test ​

The following table contains hypothetical readings to demonstrate how direct shear test results can be presented and interpreted. These are not actual laboratory observations.​

Test​
Normal stress (kPa)​
Peak shear stress (kPa)​
Displacement at peak (mm)​
1​
50​
38​
3.0​
2​
100​
68​
4.0​
3​
150​
98​
5.0​

The readings show that peak shear stress increases as normal stress increases.
This behaviour is expected because a higher normal load generally increases the contact forces and frictional resistance between soil particles.

For these illustrative values, the failure envelope is:
τ = 8 + 0.60σ

Comparing this equation with the Mohr-Coulomb equation:
τ = c + σ tan φ

We obtain:
Cohesion, c = 8 kPa
tan φ = 0.60
Angle of internal friction, φ = tan⁻¹(0.60)
Angle of internal friction, φ ≈ 31°

Therefore, the illustrative shear strength parameters are:
Cohesion = 8 kPa and Angle of Internal Friction = 31°.

These values are only an example of how results can be calculated. Actual values must be determined from the readings obtained during your experiment.
​

Discussion and Interpretation of Direct Shear Test Results​

The results of the Direct Shear Test provide useful information about the mechanical behaviour of soil.
In the illustrative example, the peak shear stress increased from 38 kPa to 98 kPa as the normal stress increased from 50 kPa to 150 kPa.
This indicates that the soil developed greater resistance against sliding under higher vertical pressure.
The calculated friction angle of approximately 31° represents the frictional contribution to the shear strength in this example. A higher friction angle generally indicates greater frictional resistance between soil particles, although it must always be interpreted in relation to soil type, density, drainage condition and testing procedure.
The cohesion intercept of 8 kPa represents the intercept of the fitted failure envelope. It should not automatically be interpreted as true bonding in the soil. In granular soils, a small apparent cohesion value may result from sample preparation, moisture, particle effects or experimental variation.
The displacement at peak shear stress also increased in the example. This suggests that the specimens reached their maximum resistance at different horizontal movements under different normal stresses.
For a proper laboratory discussion, the following points should be considered:
Whether the shear stress increased gradually or reached a clear peak.
Whether the soil showed a reduction in resistance after peak strength.
Whether the specimen compressed or expanded during shearing.
Whether the results followed a reasonably straight failure envelope.
Whether the calculated cohesion and friction angle were consistent with the soil type and observed condition.
The stress-displacement graph is particularly useful. Dense granular soils may show a distinct peak followed by reduced resistance, while loose granular soils may show a more gradual increase towards a relatively stable value.
​

Limitations of Direct Shear Apparatus​


Although the Direct Shear Test is widely used, it has some limitations that engineers and laboratory professionals should understand.​
  1. Predetermined failure plane : The soil is forced to fail along the horizontal plane between the two halves of the shear box. In actual field conditions, failure may occur along a different and weaker plane.​
  2. Non-uniform stress distribution : The distribution of normal and shear stresses may not be uniform across the specimen during testing.​
  3. Difficulty in measuring pore-water pressure : The conventional apparatus does not directly measure pore-water pressure. This makes interpretation of saturated fine-grained soil behaviour more difficult.​
  4. Drainage control : The rate of shearing must be selected according to the soil type and drainage condition. If the rate is unsuitable, the measured strength may not represent the intended condition.​
  5. Sample disturbance : Improper sampling, trimming or placement can change the natural structure and density of the soil, affecting the test results.​
  6. Particle-size restriction : The standard method under IS 2720 (Part 13) applies to soils with a maximum particle size of 4.75 mm. Larger particles require an appropriate alternative or modified testing method.​
  7. Limited stress conditions : The apparatus does not reproduce every stress condition experienced by soil in the field. A triaxial test may be more suitable when a more controlled and comprehensive stress assessment is required.​
​

Precautions During the Direct Shear Test​

To obtain reliable results, the following precautions should be followed:​

  • Prepare the soil specimen carefully and maintain the required dimensions.
  • Avoid disturbing undisturbed samples during trimming and installation.
  • Ensure that the shear box is properly assembled before applying the load.
  • Check the calibration of the proving ring or load cell.
  • Set the dial gauges correctly before starting the experiment.
  • Apply the normal load carefully and avoid sudden loading.
  • Remove the locking pins before starting the shearing stage.
  • Maintain the specified rate of shearing.
  • Record readings at regular intervals without skipping observations.
  • Use the appropriate corrected area when calculating shear stress.
  • Conduct separate tests under different normal stresses using comparable specimens.
  • Follow the relevant IS code and laboratory testing instructions.

Difference Between Direct Shear Test and Triaxial Test​

Both tests are used to determine the shear strength of soil, but their methods are different.​

Parameter​
Direct Shear Test​
Triaxial Test​
Testing arrangement​
Split shear box​
Cylindrical specimen​
Failure plane​
Predetermined​
Not predetermined​
Stress control​
More limited​
More comprehensive​
Equipment​
Relatively simple​
More complex​
Pore pressure measurement​
Not available in conventional apparatus​
Possible with suitable equipment​
Common application​
Granular soils and interface testing​
Detailed soil strength assessment​

The choice of test depends on the soil type, design requirement, drainage condition and level of accuracy required.
​

Indian Standard for Direct Shear Test​

The relevant Indian Standard is:
IS 2720 (Part 13):1986 – Methods of Test for Soils: Direct Shear Test.
This standard describes methods for determining soil shear strength under undrained, consolidated-undrained and consolidated-drained conditions, within its stated scope.
For the shear box equipment, the relevant specification should also be checked, along with any applicable amendments and current laboratory requirements.

The Direct Shear Test is an important laboratory method used in geotechnical engineering to determine the shear strength characteristics of soil. It helps engineers understand how soil behaves when subjected to vertical pressure and horizontal shearing force.
The Direct Shear Apparatus works by placing a soil specimen inside a split shear box, applying a normal load and then gradually applying horizontal movement until the soil reaches its shear resistance or the specified termination condition.
The test provides two important shear strength parameters: cohesion and angle of internal friction. These parameters are useful in foundation design, slope stability analysis, retaining wall design, embankment construction and other geotechnical applications.
Although the test has limitations, its simple arrangement, practical operation and useful results make it an important part of geotechnical laboratory testing.
For reliable results, proper specimen preparation, correct loading, suitable shearing rate, accurate readings and compliance with IS 2720 (Part 13) are essential.
​

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Direct shear test Apparatus ​

​

Q1. What is the main purpose of the Direct Shear Test?​

The main purpose is to determine the shear strength parameters of soil, particularly cohesion and the angle of internal friction.​

Q2. Which apparatus is used for the Direct Shear Test?​

A Direct Shear Testing Machine is used. Its main components include a shear box, loading frame, proving ring or load cell, normal loading arrangement and displacement dial gauges.​

Q3. Which Indian Standard is followed for the Direct Shear Test?​

The test is covered under IS 2720 (Part 13):1986.​

Q4. What is cohesion in soil?​

Cohesion is the component of soil shear strength associated with attraction or bonding between soil particles. The measured cohesion intercept should be interpreted in the context of soil type and test conditions.​

Q5. What is the angle of internal friction?​

It is a parameter that represents the frictional resistance between soil particles when they tend to slide against one another.​

Q6. Why are different normal loads applied during the test?​

Different normal loads are used to obtain several normal stress and peak shear stress values. These values are plotted to determine the failure envelope and calculate cohesion and the angle of internal friction.​

Q7. What are the main limitations of the Direct Shear Test?​

The main limitations include a predetermined failure plane, possible non-uniform stress distribution, limited pore-pressure measurement and sensitivity to drainage conditions.​

Q8. Where is the Direct Shear Test used in civil engineering?​

It is used in foundation engineering, slope stability studies, retaining wall design, embankment construction, pavement projects and soil-interface testing.​